ASIANMASC亜細亜男子SUBSCRIBE
ISSUE 001SUMMER 2026

CI-7CONSULTING RECRUITING CHAPTER 8 OF 10REVIEWED 2026-07-31

Consulting interviews: behavioral and case

Prepare for a two-way evaluation of experience, motivation, problem solving, communication, and collaboration.

The case isn't won by naming a framework. The interviewer needs to see a clear decision question, a logical breakdown, focused analysis, and an answer-first synthesis.

WHAT THIS CHAPTER TEACHES

  • In behavioral answers, state the point early, then support it with the situation, your exact actions, the result, and what you learned.
  • In a case, clarify the decision, success measure, time horizon, and constraints before building the structure.
  • Create an issue tree with the main question at the top, two to four major questions beneath it, and smaller testable questions below those.
  • Prioritize one branch with a provisional hypothesis instead of analyzing every branch equally.
  • After each calculation or exhibit, state the implication for the hypothesis.
  • At the end, use the Minto Pyramid: recommendation first, two or three supporting reasons, principal risk, and next step.
  • Verify whether the process also includes online cases, written cases, group work, expertise interviews, or assessments.

The case sequence

  1. Clarify: What decision must be made, for whom, by when, and against which measure?
  2. Structure: Break the decision into answerable questions.
  3. Prioritize: State which branch you would test first and why.
  4. Analyze: Use data, calculations, and business judgment.
  5. Update: Change the hypothesis when the evidence changes.
  6. Synthesize: Give the answer first, then the reasons, risk, and next step.

A behavioral answer also has a pyramid

Lead with the answer to the interviewer’s question. Then give only the context needed, explain your own actions, show the result, and end with the lesson. Don't force the interviewer to wait through two minutes of background to discover the point.

The behavioral interview

Behavioral or personal-experience interviews examine leadership, influence, conflict, failure, motivation, and learning. Lead with the answer to the question, provide only necessary context, explain personal actions, and state the result and lesson.

The case interview

A case is a collaborative discussion around a business or organizational problem. The candidate clarifies the decision, structures the problem, analyzes data, calculates, updates the hypothesis, and synthesizes a recommendation.

Clarification

Identify the objective, success measure, time horizon, scope, customer, geography, and constraints. Ask questions that change the structure or first analysis, not every possible fact.

Structure

Build an issue tree tailored to the problem. Explain why the branches matter and where to begin. A memorized framework can omit the actual decision.

Analysis

Interpret exhibits, perform calculations, brainstorm, and request relevant data. State the implication after each step. A correct number without business meaning doesn't advance the case.

Updating

The starting hypothesis is provisional. When evidence changes, revise the view and structure. Interviewer guidance is information, not a sign of failure.

Final synthesis

Use an answer-first pyramid: recommendation, supporting reasons, quantified evidence, principal risk, and next step. Avoid a chronological recap of everything discussed.

Other formats

Processes can include written cases, online cases, role simulations, group exercises, expertise interviews, or technical assessments. The same principles of clear decision framing and evidence apply, but the output can differ.

Candidate questions

Ask about project work, staffing, feedback, practice changes, and development. The interview is also a diligence process for the role.

CURRENT AS OF 2026-07-31

Current McKinsey materials describe personal-experience and problem-solving interviews and role-dependent assessments. Bain and BCG likewise use case and behavioral components but can differ by role and office.

SOURCES

  1. 01Barbara Minto: The Minto Pyramid Principle and SCQ Framework
  2. 02McKinsey: Interviewing
  3. 03McKinsey: Solve
  4. 04Bain: Case Interview
  5. 05BCG: Case Interview Preparation
  6. 06McKinsey — Interviewing
  7. 07Bain — Interviewing
  8. 08BCG — Interview Process
Next
COMMENTS